Was the Caveman Diet Healthier than Our Own?

Was the Caveman Diet Healthier than Our Own?

Except for Captain Caveman and Fred Flintstone, were there other overweight cavemen? Would we be healthier if we adopted the diet that ancient humans ate thousands of years ago?

What is your favorite diet? The Atkins diet? South Beach diet?

Ever heard of the paleolithic (paleo) diet?

The paleo diet is exclusively eating natural and unprocessed foods similar to those foods that ancient humans ate during the Paleolithic Period. The assumption is that ancient humans ate a healthier diet based on what they could hunt and gather.

Ancient humans were much more active because they had to be, while modern humans can inversely choose not to be active and eat unhealthy foods, with consequences like obesity, heart disease, lactose intolerance and so on.

But can you really compare the diets of ancient and modern humans?

Cavemen, the hunters and gatherers of fruits and nuts. Photo by epaleocookbooks.net.

1) What is the paleo diet?

The paleo diet, also known as the caveman diet, was first popularized in the 1970s by Walter L. Voegtlin, a gastroenterologist. The belief is that evolution is not only evident in physical characteristics but also in terms of physiology.

Because modern humans have directly evolved from the ancient humans of the Paleo Era, as opposed to humans who lived before the Paleolithic Period, it is believed modern humans are genetically inclined to adapt to such a strict diet.

Paleo diet friendly bagels made without sugar, flour or grain. Cavemen liked it simple. Photo by dionhinchcliffe.

2) When was the Paleolithic Period? What did people eat back then?

The Paleolithic Period lasted well over 2 million years and ended over 10,000 years ago with the advent of modern agriculture. The ancient humans of this time were extremely active, following and hunting their food as well as gathering vegetables, fruits, nuts, mushrooms and more.

They would have eaten grass fed and naturally lean animals, smaller animals and eggs—foods that are natural and unprocessed.

Tuna and avocado salad—refreshing after a day of dinosaur hunting. Photo by Amber Karnes.

3) How does the paleo diet match up with the diet of modern humans?

Ancient humans did NOT eat sugar, refined sugar, salt, legumes or dairy products. Does any of that sound familiar?

Modern humans eat grain-fed animals as opposed to only wild animals, and we consume processed oils and sugar in almost everything. Ancient humans didn’t eat cheese, cream, butter, ice cream and other such dairy products.  If you like candy bars and sweets, too bad, because on the paleo diet you can only eat raw honey and coconut water in limited amounts, like a caveman.

Access to and abuse of fast and unhealthy food has created sedentary and idle lifestyles for many modern people. High blood pressure, obesity, heart disease, diabetes, the list of health problems afflicting modern humans goes on and on.

Butternut squash and apple soup. Photo by elana’s pantry.

4) Can this diet work effectively in the modern era?

Can most modern humans adapt to exclusively eating just lean proteins, vegetables and fruits? Most people eat processed food and livestock animals, not just wild animals. People who hunt wild game usually eat it in addition to modern food.

With the advent of genetically modified foods and livestock exclusively fed grain, not to mention the snack, fast food and soda water industries as constant diet-breaking temptations, is it even possible for us to eat like the caveman?

Strangely enough, while the paleo diet is popular with people for popularity’s sake, polls taken in June 2011 by US News and World Report and the Daily Mail showed that the diet would likely disappoint users and is considered bottom-barrel effective when ranked with other media fad diets.

Some research shows that the diet along with commitment is effective in the short term. Most existing studies of the diet, though, are small in scale and would be far more conclusive with large-scale scientific studies.

Arugula salad with raspberries and raspberry vinaigrette. Photo by elana’s pantry.

5) So, should you try the paleo diet?

Recreating such a diet from existing modern food stocks would be very difficult. Surveys say it is one of the lowest ranked diets and is hard to commit to long term.

If you are a vegan or generally consume less animal protein than most people as well as exercise regularly, then you may already be living the modern equivalent of the paleo diet.

Committing to a diet or food lifestyle based on mass and media popularity won’t help your determination to stick with it in the long run. Ask yourself, “How long does the latest fad stay popular anyway?”

Grain-free, gluten- free, lightly sweetened coconut bars. Photo by elana’s pantry.

Have you tried the paleo diet? Let me know in the comments below.

If you liked this, you might also like: The History of Sushi.

Main photo: The Wonderful Paleo Art of Heinrich Harder.


Author Description

Lane F. Narscil

Add a comment

Comments (10)

  1. Nada Wednesday - 02 / 05 / 2012 Reply
    Actually, the paleo diet was the best thing that ever happened to me. I used to suffer from extreme anemia, now I feel better than ever. I'm more energetic, and my sleeping has improved. It was hard at first, but I adapted after 2 months. Now, I no longer crave sugar, junk food or any other unhealthy food. I have also lost 20 kg since then.
  2. Bill Wednesday - 09 / 05 / 2012 Reply
    This diet is not a "diet" for losing weight. It is a diet designed to provide energy and sustenance for elite athletes. It's purpose is to provide the ultimate in lean proteins and avoid carbohydrates that our body has difficulty processing from an athlete's point of view.
  3. Howie Saturday - 15 / 12 / 2012 Reply
    I have been on the caveman diet for 1 1/2 years. I love it. I have lost 50 pounds and have kept it off. I am more intune with what my body needs, it kinda tells you. If I am feeling sluggish I eat a banana etc... You can eat like a caveman in today's market or close to it. My doctor was going to put me on medication to reduce my bad cholesterol. I told him to wait to see what my new diet did and he was amazed at how my level dropped. I'm not even close to a bad reading. This IS the way I will eat for the rest of my life. I don't feel like I'm missing out on any foods. It doesn't really cost more to eat like this because you aren't eating as much so you buy less. Portion control is key too!
  • Carnival of Evolution, May 2012 « Nothing in biology makes sense! - May 2, 2012

    […] discussion of how sloths and turtles evolved to move slowly, and whether the diet of early humans was more healthy than ours. And there’s even a few contributions from this very blog. Go now and read the whole thing. […]

  • 5 Mathematical Foods from Around the World - May 8, 2012

    […] If you liked this article, you might also like: Was the Caveman Diet Healthier than Our Own? […]

  • In America, I Eat … Therefore I Am! | Julie's Fresh Air - May 14, 2012

    […] Was the Caveman Diet Healthier than Our Own? (theflyingfugu.com) […]

  • What IsThe Paleo Diet? « mytopweightloss - May 23, 2012

    […] Was the Caveman Diet Healthier than Our Own? (theflyingfugu.com) […]

  • Beginning my adventure in Paleo … or is it Primal? « My Journey to Godliness! - May 28, 2012

    […] Was the Caveman Diet Healthier than Our Own? (theflyingfugu.com) […]

  • a diet for human physiology « power of language blog: partnering with reality by JR Fibonacci - June 16, 2012

    […] Was the Caveman Diet Healthier than Our Own? (theflyingfugu.com) […]

  • -->

    Add a comment